Skip to content

Chris Matthews’s All-White Panel Notes Melanin Deficiency in Palin Audience

November 19, 2009

Chris Matthews has been covering “Palinpallooza” all week, alternating between gushing over her personal popularity and condescending jabs at her intellect.  Mostly, however, he’s been saying not to underestimate her, and exclaiming “I’ve never seen anything like this.”

So, Wednesday, on the opening day of Palin’s huge book signing tour, it was time for Chris to get back in the MSNBC fold, and call her a racist and a “mean girl.” (I couldn’t find a na-na-na-na-NAH-nah in the transcript, but I could’ve sworn I heard one…)

NBC’s Norah O’Donnell was covering the Palin tour on location, while Chris brought in’s resident hater, Joan Walsh, San Francisco’s female version of Keith Olbermann.

The first thing this group of faces so pale that color TV is irrelevant noticed was that the crowd did not look like they were in line for the next Tyler Perry movie.

O’DONNELL: … This is a largely white—almost no minorities in this crowd….

MATTHEWS:  Well, they look like a white crowd to me.  Let‘s go back to Joan Walsh.  Not that there‘s anything wrong with it, but it is pretty monochromatic up there.  Joan, no surprise in terms of the ethnic nature of the people showing up.  Nothing wrong with that.  But it is a fact

Yeah, well I’d like to get a look at the racial demographics of Hardball with Chris Matthews sometime… oh, wait, I buy TV commercials for a living.  I have seen them.  They’re as “monochromatic” as the line for Sarah Palin’s book signing.

Oh, and Chris’s lineup for the night, was 8 white people out of 9.  “Nothing wrong with that.  But it’s a fact.”  Indeed.

The fact that Norah O’Donnell went to Grand Rapids– which is so Dutch that the most common use of “van” is not to describe something you drive the soccer team in, but is the first part of the family name– and found white people(!) is quite a scoop.

But believe it or not, the conversation went downhill from there.

And of course we couldn’t have a Palin conversation with this group without a Tina Fey reference, no matter how oblique…

MATTHEWS:  Let me go to this intramural—the nastiness—and I want to get back to Norah on this, Norah covered the campaign and—the nastiness of this, the attacks on you might call them the “little people,” Steve Schmidt, Nicolle Wallace, in the campaign.  Here‘s somebody who was governor of a state taking whacks in a published book, her only book, trashing little people, and at the same time, she‘s looking out for little…

JOAN WALSH, SALON.COM:  I—there are questions about who‘s right, but they strenuously deny it, and other reporters who were around also deny her version of things. So, I think that there are a couple of whopping lies, as well as just a mean-spiritedness that doesn‘t serve her well.

It‘s why she will never be president.  She is a very divisive, mean-spirited person.  She is fighting down with her 19-year-old ex-future-son-in-law, who should really be ignored, if anything.

So, you know, I think you see a side of Sarah Palin—Norah is right.  People who love her love her.  But the general public doesn‘t trust her and sees this kind of mean girl persona that she‘s never grown out of…

Why is Chris Matthews in the junior high girls locker room with Joan Walsh talking catty?  This just beggars description, but let me try.

To act as though the year of leaks, anonymous sniping and backstabbing over just who was responsible for everything from Sarah Palin’s wardrobe to her media scheduling– to selecting her in the first place– was initiated by PALIN is just plain nuts.  To characterize 12 pages out of 400 as a dominant mean streak is just goofy.  Frankly, after the way McCain’s staff has spent the last year acting, I’m a little disappointed it’s not 12 chapters.

Part of what Palin is now being criticized for is not getting on board with the worst campaign tactic in recent Presidential history– the official announcement that McCain was abandoning the swing state of Michigan.  Yeah, they were the political pros…

But who cares about that, it turns out that Sarah Palin is a… racist!   (Of course, Chris Matthews and Joan Walsh have blown this “dog whistle” before.)

MATTHEWS:  … on “Sean Hannity” last night. I think there is a tribal aspect to this thing, in other words, white vs. other people.  I think she is very smart about this.  Here she is on the issue of—of what happened down at Fort Hood, obviously, an ethnic issue, as many people see it.

WALSH:  Right.

MATTHEWS:  She sees it that way.  Here she is going at him.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP, “HANNITY”)  SEAN HANNITY, HOST, “HANNITY”:  Do you think Fort Hood was an act of terrorism?

SARAH PALIN ®, FORMER ALASKA GOVERNOR:  I certainly do.  And I think that there were massive warning flags that were missed all over the place.  And it was quite unfortunate that, to me, it was a fear of being politically incorrect, to not—I‘m going to use the word—profile this guy, profiling in the sense of finding out what his radical beliefs were.

Now, because I used the word profile, I‘m going to get clobbered tomorrow morning.  The liberals, their heads are just going to be spinning.  They are going to say, she is radical.  She is extreme.

But I say profiling in the context of doing whatever we can to save innocent American lives, I‘m all for it then.  (END VIDEO CLIP)

MATTHEWS:  No.  Profiling has a particular meaning.  Joan, you go at it.  Everybody knows what profiling is.

WALSH:  Right.

MATTHEWS:  It‘s driving while black.

Or, it’s shooting while Muslim.  Or calling al Qaeda while Army.  Or lecturing about killing infidels while teaching at Walter Reed.  Or trying to prosecute your own patients for war crimes while a psychiatrist….

WALSH:  Black.

MATTHEWS:  We know what it means.  If you come from a Middle Eastern country, keep your eye on this guy.  Check him out.

MATTHEWS:  That‘s profiling.

O‘DONNELL:  Listen, the same day she is complaining about the “Newsweek” cover, which, actually, I also did find sexist, but she is making herself a victim around the “Newsweek” cover while endorsing profiling?

Yes, I remember that NBC TV show called “Profiler.”  I’d forgotten it was about a woman FBI agent who tried to stop black people from driving.  Oh, and that CBS show “Criminal Minds,” isn’t it about a whole klan of FBI agents who try to suppress voting rights?

The only thing more pallid about this ditzy crew than their skin tone is their opinions.

  1. Wynn permalink
    November 19, 2009 10:16 pm

    Be careful of apple/orange comparisons, Mr. Forsmark. The lack of heterogeneity among Palin’s followers is significant. Why? Because it says something about who she attracts and who she doesn’t — especially if her crowds generally look similar to the one being shown.

    On the other hand, the makeup of the panel on that night’s Hardball was not significant. Why not? Because it didn’t necessarily reflect who watches Chris. It wasn’t as though the host of a show that only white people watch was criticizing an author that only white people read. (Plus Chris’s panels are frequently mixed in terms of gender and race.)

    So — I’d have to call cheap shot on your title.

    • David Forsmark permalink
      November 19, 2009 10:36 pm

      Chris averages about one non-white guest per night. And bringing gender into your mix doesn’t work. Palin’s crowd is mixed “in terms of gender.” So, what percentage of Palin’s crowd should be black? A bunch of white people sitting around saying look at that white crowd, whose (very small) viewership is about as white as Palin’s crowd is pretty shameless.

    • Kent Harrison permalink
      November 20, 2009 5:47 am

      Your no Wynner, just another F’n Wynnier

  2. bobs permalink
    November 20, 2009 2:08 am

    When a person gives away copies of his Koran just before slaughtering his victims in gunfire, while screaming out Allahu akbur, I think we can note who is making religion an issue here, and it ain’t Palin.

  3. Sam Deakins permalink
    November 20, 2009 4:18 am

    I can’t wait for the Kwame Kilpatrick book tour. Wonder what the melanin level of the crowds will be then.

    • David Forsmark permalink
      November 20, 2009 6:30 am

      There will be the same number of black people in line for a Kwame book as Sarah’s book. Higher percentage, maybe, but same number– at most.

      • John Davidson permalink
        November 20, 2009 10:05 am

        Maybe, ACORN will see that a lot of people show up with government vouchers.

  4. nash permalink
    November 20, 2009 6:31 am

    David Forsmark, well done for pointing out the monochromatic makeup of the Matthews panel. But what about that crowd in Michigan? Maybe it is racist of non whites to avoid HER. Why did non whites choose to not show up? Does Barnes and Noble have a whites only night? Did Barnes and Noble embargo non whites? Give me a break Hardball. Let Americans make free will choices and stop stirring up hatred. And quit makin’ things up.

    • renee permalink
      November 20, 2009 11:00 am

      There were no blacks and barely any people of color in line for Sarah Palin’s book signing because the most people of color know racist/racism when they see and hear it. As a person of color, I have been subjected to racism all my life, both subtle and not so subtle. Therefore I am uniquely qualified to make that assessment.

      • Erika permalink
        November 23, 2009 10:53 am

        Renee, as a woman of color, I’m uniquely qualified to tell you that you’re an idiot. Stop being a victim and educate yourself. White conservatives are not boogey-men. Or boogey-women.

        • onsal permalink
          November 25, 2009 8:21 pm


  5. Theodore Blunt permalink
    November 20, 2009 8:33 am

    C. Matthews is a blot on the American education system.

  6. Jay Kanter permalink
    November 20, 2009 8:40 am

    Mr.Forsmark,Msnbc is an arm of the Democratic party.Thats their purpose to say anything to belittle republicians or conservatives.The best advise i can give you is do not waste your time watching msnbc.

  7. John Davidson permalink
    November 20, 2009 9:47 am

    No crowd; no news, Chris.

    No one watching; no job, Chris.

  8. jason gray permalink
    November 20, 2009 3:26 pm

    how many non-whites host shows on MSNBC?

  9. November 20, 2009 4:09 pm

    Marxo-Sapien media hacks and bloggers against Sister Sarah is the gift that keeps on giving right through 2012. The more they overcrowd the hate Sarah Palin Express, the more real Americans jump on board the love Sister Sarah Express. Keep on spouting hate diatribe American Pravda and graduates of the Joseph Goebbels School of Misinformation.

    The Turban Torpedo

  10. Diana permalink
    November 20, 2009 4:58 pm

    It is comments like this from Matthews that is tearing up our country. Stop it please. Hate speech never bears good fruit.

  11. November 20, 2009 6:52 pm

    Who is Chris Matthews? Oh he must be the sleaze ball on the CNN site that said there is nothing wrong with a Major in the United States Military sending Emails to Al quida. Maybe someday an Al quida operative like Major Hasan will detonate an explosive strapped to their body in the presence of the CNN studios. If we continue to deny the presence of terrorist amongst us, something that apparantly Matthews and others of his ilk continue to do, then its only a matter of time, before the next Fort Hood takes place. Id bet old reruns of leave it to beaver would draw higher rating then Matthews. Geez Wally, is that Sleaze ball Matthews still on the tube? lol

  12. November 21, 2009 6:33 pm

    I wonder if Chris has reported on Jesse “Hymietown” Jackson’s most recent racist comment about “you can’t vote against the health care bill and still call yourself a black man”.

    This reminds me of CNN sniping about how few blacks there were at the GOP Bush convention about the same time CNN was running an ad in the WSJ. In the ad there was a group picture of all the reporters, @40 of them, with Bernard Shaw being the only person of color.


  1. Polls show that polls are mostly bunk « NewsReal Blog
  2. 17 Year-Old Girl Blogger 3, NBC’s Star Reporter Norah O’Donnell 0 « NewsReal Blog
  3. Even Media Matters speechless over Matthew’s ‘enemy camp’ line « NewsReal Blog

Comments are closed.